# What people get wrong about dual agency in California

Dual agency is legal in California, as long as the buyer and the seller both know about it and agree to it. One brokerage on both sides counts as dual agency, even when 2 different agents in 2 different offices do the work.

By Based staff. Published 2026-11-17. Listicle, Agents.

Canonical: https://based.insure/agents/dual-agency-california-myths/

## The short version

- Dual agency is legal in California only when the buyer and the seller both know about it and consent.
- When one brokerage represents both sides, that's dual agency, even if each side has its own salesperson.
- A dual agent can't tell the seller your top price, or tell you the seller's bottom line, without express permission.
- Nothing in California law makes the commission smaller in a dual agency deal, so negotiate it in writing before you agree.

> This article is general information about California law. It isn't legal advice for your situation.

## What counts as dual agency in California?

Dual agency is when one agent represents both the buyer and the seller in the same deal. California's Civil Code section 2079.13 defines a [dual agent](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.13) as an agent acting for both sides "either directly or through a salesperson or broker associate."

That second half matters more than it looks. In California the "agent" in a deal is the broker. Salespeople work under a broker's license. When the brokerage is a company, the company is the agent. So 2 salespeople at the same brokerage, one on each side, make the brokerage a dual agent.

Here are 7 beliefs about dual agency, checked one at a time against the statute and the courts.

## 1. "Dual agency is illegal in California"

**Verdict: wrong.** It's legal with disclosure and consent. The disclosure form is written into Civil Code section 2079.16. It says an agent "[can legally be the agent of both the Seller and the Buyer](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.16) in a transaction, but only with the knowledge and consent of both."

The California Supreme Court said the same thing in 2016. A broker may act as a dual agent "provided both parties consent to the arrangement after full disclosure," it wrote in [*Horiike v. Coldwell Banker*](https://www4.courts.ca.gov/opinions/archive/S218734.PDF).

What's off limits is the hidden version. The California Department of Real Estate (DRE) lists undisclosed dual agency as a red flag for buyers. It says that if an agent represents both sides, [that representation "must be disclosed and agreeable to both parties."](https://www.dre.ca.gov/consumers/consumeralerts/ConsumerAlert_20241114_Changes_to_Real_Estate_Representation.html)

## 2. "It's only dual agency if one agent works both sides"

**Verdict: wrong.** One brokerage on both sides is enough. The *Horiike* case shows how that plays out.

A family trust listed a house in Malibu with Chris Cortazzo, a salesperson in Coldwell Banker's Malibu West office. The September 2006 listing said the house offered "approximately 15,000 square feet of living areas." The building permit described a 9,224 square foot house, a 746 square foot guest house and a 1,080 square foot garage.

The buyer, Hiroshi Horiike, worked with Chizuko Namba in Coldwell Banker's Beverly Hills office. They were different people in different offices. The confirmation form Horiike signed still named Coldwell Banker as the agent of both the buyer and the seller, because the brokerage was the agent on each side.

After the sale, Horiike sued over the square footage. The question for the Supreme Court was whether the seller's salesperson owed the buyer anything. The court held that he owed the buyer the same duty of disclosure the brokerage did, which the statute calls "equivalent." Today's statute says the same. When a salesperson [owes a duty to any principal, "that duty is equivalent to the duty owed to that party by the broker."](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.13)

At a large brokerage, the agent across the table may work for the same company as yours. Ask before you make an offer.

## 3. "Signing the agency disclosure form means I agreed to dual agency"

**Verdict: wrong.** That form explains your options. It isn't a choice among them.

Under Civil Code section 2079.14, your agent gives you the disclosure form and gets back [a "signed acknowledgment of receipt."](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.14) A buyer's agent has to hand it over as soon as practicable, before you sign a buyer agreement or an offer. The form describes every kind of agency relationship. It also warns that you may get more than one copy during a deal.

The relationship in your actual deal is confirmed somewhere else. Section 2079.17 says each agent has to tell you whether it's acting [for you alone or as a dual agent](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.17). The answer goes into the purchase contract or a separate writing, signed before or when you sign the contract.

So the line to read is the confirmation in your contract. It names your agent's role for this house.

## 4. "A dual agent will tell the seller my top price"

**Verdict: wrong, unless you say they can.** Civil Code section 2079.21 says a dual agent may not, without the buyer's express permission, [pass the buyer's confidential information to the seller](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.21). The same rule protects the seller's information from the buyer.

"Confidential information" in that section covers more than price. It means facts about your financial position, your motivations and your bargaining position. It also covers any other personal information that may affect price. The statute's own examples are a seller who'd take less than the listing price and a buyer who'd pay more than their offer.

The section's current wording has been in force since January 1, 2019. The older version, which the Supreme Court quoted in 2016, covered price only and called for "express written consent." Either way, nobody can make you give permission. You don't have to tell the agent your ceiling at all.

## 5. "A dual agent doesn't owe me anything"

**Verdict: wrong, with a real catch.** The statutory form says a dual agent owes both sides ["a fiduciary duty of utmost care, integrity, honesty, and loyalty."](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.16)

The same form lists duties every agent owes the buyer and the seller alike. They include reasonable skill and care, honest and fair dealing and good faith. They also include a duty to disclose all facts the agent knows that materially affect the property's value or desirability. Section 2079.21's confidentiality rule doesn't change any duty about information other than price.

Here's the catch. A dual agent can't use what one side said privately to push the other side on price. So in a dual agency deal, nobody is bargaining hard for you with inside knowledge. The form says the agent's duties "[do not relieve a Seller or Buyer from the responsibility to protect their own interests.](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.16)" We read that as a plain instruction. Decide your own price and verify the facts yourself, because in *Horiike* the square footage only came out after the sale.

Whether the house can be insured is one of those facts. The duty to disclose covers facts the agent knows, but nobody knows what an insurer will say until one is asked.

Start with the home's claims history report, called a CLUE report. You can't order it yourself. [Utah's insurance department explains](https://insurance.utah.gov/consumers/clue/) that under the federal FACT Act, it "can only be accessed by the owner, insurer or lender." So ask the seller to order it.

Then ask for a quote on the address before you remove any contingency. Casa quotes California homes with standard insurers first and specialty insurers after them. <a href="https://casa.insure/learn/check-home-insurance-before-buying-california" rel="nofollow">The list of insurance checks to run before an offer</a> from Casa, whose team runs this site, goes through the roof and the wiring too.

## 6. "Dual agency means a smaller commission"

**Verdict: not automatically.** The agency sections of the Civil Code that we checked set duties and paperwork. They don't set pay.

The DRE says [commissions are fully negotiable under California law](https://www.dre.ca.gov/consumers/consumeralerts/ConsumerAlert_20241114_Changes_to_Real_Estate_Representation.html). It adds that an agent who claims there's a "standard" rate is misrepresenting the law. Section 2079.19 says who pays an agent [doesn't by itself decide who the agent represents](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.19). It also lets the listing agent and the buyer's agent split a commission.

So whether one brokerage collecting both sides charges less is something you negotiate. A seller does it in the listing agreement. A buyer does it in the buyer-broker representation agreement, which has to state the agent's pay. If the answer isn't written down, assume nothing changed.

## 7. "If I go straight to the listing agent, they become my agent"

**Verdict: wrong.** Civil Code section 2079.22 says that a buyer who chooses not to have an agent [doesn't, by itself, make the seller's agent a dual agent](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.22). You'd simply be a buyer without representation. The DRE's regulation adds that a seller's agent showing a home for the seller alone [isn't acting as a buyer's agent](https://www.dre.ca.gov/files/pdf/relaw/2025/AB2992_Title_10_CalCodeofRegs29061_29063.pdf). That's true at an open house or any other showing.

The listing agent still owes you honest and fair dealing and the disclosure of material facts, because the form lists those duties to both sides. They don't owe you a fiduciary duty, though. The Supreme Court noted in *Horiike* that the form gives an agent for one side no fiduciary duty to the other.

If you want the listing agent to represent you too, that's dual agency. It comes with paperwork. Since January 1, 2025, every agent who represents a buyer has to sign a buyer-broker representation agreement with that buyer. Civil Code section 1670.50 requires that agreement "as soon as practicable, but no later than the execution of the buyer's offer." If you already signed with another agent, check your agreement first. The DRE says you can approach the seller's agent about dual agency only if your agreement lets you do it [without owing your own agent](https://www.dre.ca.gov/consumers/consumeralerts/ConsumerAlert_20241114_Changes_to_Real_Estate_Representation.html).

## If you're offered dual agency, ask these first

1. **Who is the brokerage on each side?** Two agents can have different names and offices and still work for one brokerage.
2. **What does my agreement say?** Check whether your buyer agreement or listing agreement allows dual agency. Find out what you'd owe if you go that way.
3. **What happens to the commission?** Get any change in writing in the agreement, before you sign the offer.
4. **What won't you tell me?** Ask the agent to walk you through what they can't share from the other side under section 2079.21.
5. **What if I say no?** Section 2079.20 lets an agent [choose the kind of agency it will accept](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.20) as a condition of working with you, as long as it discloses and confirms it. Find out before you're deep into a deal.
6. **Is everyone licensed?** You can check any agent or brokerage on the DRE's [public license lookup](https://www2.dre.ca.gov/PublicASP/pplinfo.asp).

## Questions people ask

**Is dual agency legal in California?**
Yes, with disclosure and consent. Civil Code section 2079.16 says an agent can represent both the buyer and the seller only with the knowledge and consent of both.

**Is it dual agency if my agent and the listing agent work at the same brokerage?**
Yes. California defines a dual agent as one acting for both sides directly or through a salesperson or broker associate. In a 2016 California Supreme Court case, 2 salespeople from 2 offices of one brokerage made that brokerage a dual agent.

**Can a dual agent tell the seller how much I'm willing to pay?**
Not without your express permission. Civil Code section 2079.21 bars a dual agent from passing a buyer's confidential information to the seller. That includes a willingness to pay more than the offer.

**Do I pay less commission with a dual agent in California?**
Not automatically. The California DRE says commissions are fully negotiable, so any reduction has to be negotiated and written into your agreement.

**Can I refuse dual agency?**
Yes. Dual agency needs the consent of both the buyer and the seller. A brokerage can also decline to work in a form of agency it doesn't accept, so ask early.

## Sources

- [Civil Code section 2079.13](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.13), California Civil Code (text via california.public.law)
- [Civil Code section 2079.14](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.14), California Civil Code (text via california.public.law)
- [Civil Code section 2079.16](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.16), California Civil Code (text via california.public.law)
- [Civil Code section 2079.17](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.17), California Civil Code (text via california.public.law)
- [Civil Code section 2079.19](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.19), California Civil Code (text via california.public.law)
- [Civil Code section 2079.20](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.20), California Civil Code (text via california.public.law)
- [Civil Code section 2079.21](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.21), California Civil Code (text via california.public.law)
- [Civil Code section 2079.22](https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_2079.22), California Civil Code (text via california.public.law)
- [Horiike v. Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage Co. (November 21, 2016)](https://www4.courts.ca.gov/opinions/archive/S218734.PDF), Supreme Court of California
- [Changes to Buyer Representation and Compensation](https://www.dre.ca.gov/consumers/consumeralerts/ConsumerAlert_20241114_Changes_to_Real_Estate_Representation.html), California Department of Real Estate
- [AB 2992 regulations, 10 CCR 2906.1 to 2906.3](https://www.dre.ca.gov/files/pdf/relaw/2025/AB2992_Title_10_CalCodeofRegs29061_29063.pdf), California Department of Real Estate
- [Public license lookup](https://www2.dre.ca.gov/PublicASP/pplinfo.asp), California Department of Real Estate
- [Frequently Asked Questions About C.L.U.E.](https://insurance.utah.gov/consumers/clue/), Utah Insurance Department

---

Run by the team behind Casa, a technology platform of SimpliSent, Inc.
